I’ll be the first to admit it….I tend to only go to the cinema for:
a) A film i can’t wait to see eg. Star Wars (prequels, sequels, 3-D or whatever he does next), any new James Bond film etc
b) Something that i know will benefit from a cinema setting eg. the surround sound in the Transformers movies was flying all over the shop, all the time…in a brilliant way!
c) 2 hours of mindless entertainment eg. Mission Impossible III – butt-thumping explosions are just so much better in a cinema….even if Tom Cruise’s smug mug is 10 ft bigger…
The last animated film I went to in the cinema was The Incredibles (which I loved…) and I missed Wall-E so after hearing about just how good Pixar’s new film UP was, I thought it was time to see what all this stereoscopic fuss was about!
The verdict…..in a word, stunning!
I only know the basics of how 3D works from a technical side (there’s a few blogs on it here and here and a million other places, plus this looks interesting!) and I’ve seen a few tests that the guys here in Brown Bag have been working on but i didn’t really know what to expect from a full feature in polarized 3D. If anything, in my head I was thinking it was going to be pretty subtle and not all that noticable, except for maybe the odd “I’m looking at you” finger action – in my defense I had the old tests from years ago in my head, you know the ones that promised the world but ultimately were kinda embarrassing. But I was wrong…so so wrong…
Firstly, I could not get over just how much the picture comes to life. The first few minutes was a bit weird and i thought it might become distracting but once my eyes adjusted I couldn’t believe a) how natural it looked b) how animated everything becomes – you really do feel immersed in the picture. From fluttering insects to twinkly stars and racing animals , the screen felt a lot more alive. And its probably the first time i have truly appreciated backgrounds too!
As always, a pretty stellar story helps (I guess its Pixar so that shouldn’t come as a surprise…). Its very charming and it really does pull at the heart-strings – there are some really sad moments and I can’t decide if it was a bit much for a young audience…but then I think back to Finding Nemo or Bambi, the benchmark of animated sadness!
Just like in Wall-E, the first few minutes of the film are a triumph. Most of its only animation and some great score but the core of the plot and character backgrounds are all laid out for you – you’re hooked from then on. In a way, the opening minutes of Wall-E were pretty unique until now so I’m not sure if it spoils things a little? Also, check out the end credits – very clever and original - its the first time i’ve seen people wait till the end of the credits since X-Men 3!
I have to say the 3-D really brought the surround sound to life too. Unlike you picture guys, 3-D sound has been around for donkeys but with matching picture, it really does bring something else to to the table. In a way, I actually noticed the rear and side surrounds much more than normal – it wasn’t distracting but it just had a greater impact.
I’m probably only telling you what you already know but…3D rocks! Now I’m pretty damn excited about the next Pixar creation in 3-D (Toy Story 3 anyone?) and especially Disney’s Tron 2.0/Tron Legacy – it should be spectacular and the light bikes sound just as cool as the originals did in the 80’s! Me’thinks Tron Legacy will cover a, b, & c of my cinema worthy criteria…plus d) Its in 3-D….


6 comments so far
Couldn’t agree more Dominic! Watching Up in 3D was the perfect cinema experience. No cheap tricks, it just felt like a subtle enhancement of picture that immersed you totally in the world. Such a brilliant film!
19 October 2009
4:47 pm
Completely agree Dom. I have to say I love 3D animated movies,but 3D live action is another ball game. The likes of Final Destination,Bloody Valentine and other recent efforts have just felt like the guinea pigs of 3D Blockbuster with one or two set pieces making use of the effect (ohhhh theres an axe flying towards me,Im scared!! lol).Maybe Tron and Avatar will change that,well atleast until they develop holographic feature films,now that would be AWESOME!!!
19 October 2009
5:01 pm
I fear I may be getting over excited about Tron alright…I know it was a film before it was a game but when has anything remotely connected with a video game made a decent film?! Plus very rarely are sequels as good as the original, even if it is 20 years and many millions of $’s later…but I can only hope!
19 October 2009
5:36 pm
SPEAKING OF WHICH..Ghostbusters video game is a riot and technically an sequel to the movies with the majority of the orignal cast reprising their roles.. there is now talks that they might make a new Ghostbusters movie on the back of the game,and of course the huge following of the movies,now I know i shouldnt be too optimistic but i would be very happy with this.. now that would be a live action movie Id watch in 3D..imagine a 3D Slimer!!Sweet
19 October 2009
11:34 pm
Well you’d go see a new Ghostbusters anyway (3D or not!) – it goes under the Star Wars/Bond/Indiana Jones thing where you remember loving the movies as a kid, watching a new one kinda makes you feel like a kid again – I’m guessing this was a factor in Transformers, despite all the technical wizardry going on! 3-D Slimer would be pretty cool mind you….
On a seperate note, last night I was reminded of a little show called Forty Coats on RTE – anyone remember it?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m-KnZVseNnY
Do you think Pixar took inspiration for a flying building?!
20 October 2009
8:48 am
I saw Up in 2D, but am regretting it. I think I need to go back to the cinema!!!
24 October 2009
3:54 pm